What You Should Know About The Abortion Laws: A Criminal Lawyer’s Perspective

May 24, 2019

woman-holding-sign-at-protest-What to Know About New Abortion LawsWhat to Know About New Abortion Laws

Last week the state of Alabama passed the most restrictive abortion law currently in existence in the United States of America, banning abortion outright and making it punishable (for doctor’s performing abortions) by up to 99 years in prison.

This got the world’s attention.

But this is just one piece of a very complex puzzle that goes to the heart of the legal system, human rights, and the role of government.

Let me be very clear. I believe that these laws are not about being “pro-life”. These laws are about control. These laws ensure the perpetuation of cycles of poverty. If the issue here was really about protecting life, the supporters of these bills would be advocates of greater funding to the foster care system, better access to parenting resources, and greater investment in childhood education.

They are not.

Because this is not about protecting life.

This is the systemic dismantling of women’s rights.

So what do you need to know about the new abortion laws? I’m going to break it down into categories.

  1. The Legal Background
  2. The New Laws
  3. What this Means Right Now / Current Abortion Access
  4. Next steps
  5. What YOU Can Do & How You Can Help

Disclosure: Before I get into this let me make a few things clear. 1) I’m a criminal lawyer & am sharing this information as someone who has a background in this area. I am not however giving legal advice of any kind nor do claim to be an expert on abortion law. 2) I will undoubtedly receive hate for this post. This is a highly divisive issue, but at the end of the day I cannot in good conscious stay silent. This is a full on attack on human rights & staying silent is an act of compliance. These laws and the road we are heading down will kill people. Women will die because of these laws and I cannot stand by and watch that happen. As Desmond Tutu so poignantly said;

If you are neutral in situations of injustice, you have chosen the side of the oppressor.”

1. Legal Background:

The 1973 Supreme Court of the United States decision in Roe v Wade declared abortion access a constitutionally protected legal right. This is the seminal case people refer to when discussing the legalities of abortion.

In 1992 the Court heard Planned Parenthood v Casey; a case stemming from changes to Pennsylvania’s abortions laws in the late 80’s. The Supreme Court re-affirmed Roe, though they did allow for some restrictions on abortion as sought by Pennsylvania including mandatory waiting periods.

2. Recent Changes / The New Laws:

What really launched this into the public eye is the total ban imposed by Alabama last week. This legislation is a total ban on any abortion, including where the woman was raped. Punishment for doctors performing abortions could be as high as 99 years in prison.

I should probably take this opportunity to point out that Alabama has the lowest female representation in government of any state in the United States of America. Alabama has only 15% women in state representation. Laws directly aimed at women’s bodies are being made with almost no input from women.

Sadly it does not end here. There is so much more going on than just Alabama’s abortion ban. What to Know About New Abortion Laws: Many states are using the focus on the total abortion bans to their advantage and are passing restrictive abortion legislation that effectively achieves the same result – making it de facto impossible to get an abortion despite no complete legal ban. For example; Kentucky.

In Kentucky there is only ONE remaining clinic that performs abortions.

You read that right. One clinic. For the entire state.

The governor of Kentucky, Matt Bevin, has made it clear that his goal is to make abortion illegal in Kentucky. At the time of his election three years ago, there were three clinics in Kentucky performing abortions. In just the three short years he has been in power he has succeeded in closing two of them. He is now after the one remaining clinic on what is the most ridiculous legal ground.

I’m not an expert on the case, but from what I know the current clinic operates by way of a memorandum of understanding with a nearby hospital. The way the Kentucky abortion legislation reads, this agreement is necessary for abortions to be legally performed. The current memorandum is signed by someone at the hospital, I believe it is the head of OBGYN. A case was brought forward arguing that this was not sufficient and that it was not legal without the signature of the CEO of the hospital, who refuses to sign. Therefore, the argument is that it is not legally binding and thus there is no memorandum which would allow abortions to be legally performed. This case is currently under Appeal.

And it’s not just Alabama & Kentucky. In recent months lawmakers in Arkansas, Georgia, Mississippi, Missouri, Ohio, and Utah have passed new anti-abortion bills.

When Trump was elected he made a specific campaign promise to appoint judges to the Supreme Court who would overturn Wade, and he has been living up to that. Trump has appointed two Supreme Court judges, both of whom have vocalized their anti-abortion beliefs.

 

3. Abortion Access Now – What is Legal Right Now?

What to Know About New Abortion Laws: It is important to understand legislation does not take effect immediately. As of today, abortion is still a constitutional, legal right protected in all 50 United States. The current Alabama abortion ban does not go into effect for 6 months.

Roe v Wade is still binding law, and until / if the Supreme Court of the United States takes up one of these challenges that remains the case.

That does not mean that we do not need to be worried. It is a very real possibility that Roe v Wade could be overturned, for all the reasons discussed above.

Don’t be lulled into a fall sense of security that this could all change in 2020 with the election. Even if the Democrat’s take back the senate and keep the house, this ‘war’ will continue to rage at a state level. Any changes in federal politics, while they may have a huge impact on what eventually comes down federally, will not change the hostile climate that exists at a state level in many red states. We will need to keep fighting again and again to ensure that a woman’s right to dictate the choices of her own body is protected.


4. Next Steps:

Leading the fight against these legal changes are two key organizations; the ACLU (American Civil Liberties Union) and Planned Parenthood. The ACLU currently has filed challenges to bans in both Kentucky & Ohio, and as of today’s writing, are working on filing challenges in both Alabama & Georgia. They will be filing as many challenges as they are able to.

 

5. How You Can Help:

1) Donate, Donate, Donate:
If you are financially able please donate to help the organizations fighting. I’m personally a monthly donor of the ACLU, and I highly recommend supporting them if you are able. Other great organizations include:
Planned Parenthood
Access Reproductive Care – South East (ARC)

2) Volunteer as a Clinic Escort (more info here):
If you’re able to volunteer your time, and are comfortable with being on the front lines, being there to assist a woman in need is invaluable.

3) Educate Yourself:
The more you know the more you can help. Some articles I have found helpful: Washington Post, Vox, Shondaland.

4) Speak Out!!!
Your voice is a powerful tool. Let your friends & family know what’s happening. Use your education on this issue to educate others. Use your voice to speak up to your government representatives and make sure they know where you stand on this issue.

There is a lot of work to be done, but I still believe in the power of the people and the fact that we can ensure women’s rights are protected. There are strong voices fighting for us, and we need to take up the charge with them.

What to Know About New Abortion Laws

24 responses to “What You Should Know About The Abortion Laws: A Criminal Lawyer’s Perspective”

  1. jenniferpickering22gmailcom says:

    I am disgusted in these laws. Especially the miscarriage part.

    Jennifer
    Effortlessly Sophisticated

    • Lee says:

      I know. It’s really hard to wrap your head around a lot of it; and it’s the more horrible parts (no exceptions for rape or incest or where the ‘woman’ is a minor) that really demonstrate it is not about ‘protecting life’ but enacting control.

  2. This really is such an important subject and we cannot stay silent on this issue. I am 100% in agreement with all points you hit on this controversial topic. We must keep fighting for our rights – we cannot be controlled! Such a well written and motivational post, babe. Thank you for sharing on this important topic.

    xoxo Sarah

  3. Lizzie says:

    Wow, there is a lot of information here! Thank you for bringing this into the light and sharing such an important topic!

    Lizzie
    http://www.lizzieinlace.com

    • Lee says:

      Ya, it’s a long one! I wanted to keep it short but there was just so much information to pack in! I feel like so many people don’t actually about the different laws in different states or what the ACLU is up against. Thank you so much for reading. <3

  4. kileen says:

    Such an important issue and I think we as women need to stand together, especially during this time. Thank you for sharing!

    Kileen
    cute & little

  5. gretahollar says:

    Thanks for using your platform to bring awareness to these issues! It’s so important to talk about these things.

  6. Laura S says:

    This is certainly a heated topic and one that is really important to talk about so thank you for having the courage to speak up on this public space! As a mother of a little girl, it’s hard to hear about these things in the news and know that my daughter is growing up in a world that is headed this direction.

    • Lee says:

      Thank you so much for reading it, it means so much. And yes, I can only imagine it’s so difficult having a little girl and thinking about what the world might look like for them in 5 or 10 years.

  7. madisonfichtl says:

    I love that you are sharing about this topic! I will be doing my part with a few of your suggestions!

    xo,
    Madison | Madison-Fichtl.com

  8. Jamaria says:

    This is such an important topic that not a lot of people are discussing and it needs to be discussed! I’m so disappointed in this new law. No one should be able to tell a woman what she can and cannot do with her body. Thanks for sharing girl. Xo

  9. This is the first post I’ve read on this topic from a lawyers perspective and I appreciate you sharing the legalities of it all as I’m not as well versed in that as I should be!

    -Morgan
    How 2 Wear It [] http://how2wearit.com

  10. annaefox01 says:

    This is such an informative post! Thanks for sharing!

  11. I really appreciate you putting this together Lee. This is incredibly helpful and has opened my eyes. I would have to say I 100% agree with you – this is not about protecting lives, it is about control. Not something I 100% thought before but absolutely do now. Thank you again for sharing this with us.

    xo Laura Leigh

  12. GINA BLADES says:

    Yes! These laws are about control – always have been, always will be. Thank you for sharing.

Leave a Reply